Great News! Seniorly has joined the CareScout family. We're excited to expand our services while continuing to support your family's journey. Read the full press release here.
Talk with a local advisor for free855-866-7661
Seniorly logo

Assisted Living in West Islip, NY

Headshot.jpegJF
Reviewed by Jasmine Fung

Last updated March 01, 2025

West Islip offers a diverse range of 22 Assisted Living communities giving families varied options to choose from. The average cost of assisted living living in the West Islip area is $4,530, and the communities in the West Islip area have a average rating of 9.8 out of 10. Seniorly also uses Seniorly Price Estimate for cost comparisons with nearby cities, and even highlights new construction facilities for those seeking modern amenities. Families can look at 251 photos, 1,016 ratings and reviews, and 9 prices in the West Islip area to get a sense of assisted living in the area. Not to be confused with nursing homes, which offer medical care, assisted living provides daily help with activities of daily living like dressing or bathing. And with services catering to all care levels, many facilities enable residents to age in place, whether it's a 1 bedroom or 2 bedroom option. For personalized assistance, Seniorly local advisors Jasmine Fung and Mike McClernon are available to help with your search.

The 20 Best Assisted Living Facilities in West Islip, NY

22 communities near West Islip, NY

CareScout Quality Network
Atria Bay Shore - image 1

Atria Bay Shore

53 Ocean Avenue , Bay Shore, NY 11706

Assisted Living , Memory Care , Independent Living

"My father has been a resident at The Atria Bay Shore for over a year now, and we have been so impressed with the level of care he has received. I have had all my questions answered quickly whenever there has been a care plan change or I have wanted to make special accommodations. It's also a really nice community with some great views." - Marian
...Read more
From $5,995/mo
9.9
See details
Verified
Sunrise Of West Babylon - image 1

Sunrise Of West Babylon

580 Montauk Highway, West Babylon, NY 11704

Assisted Living , Memory Care

Sunrise of West Babylon is a vibrant senior living community nestled on the South Shore of Long Island. From the moment one steps through the doors, the welcoming atmosphere is palpable, reflecting the dedication of the experienced caregivers who are committed to supporting residents' individual needs and preferences through personalized care plans. The community's focus on health and well-being i...
...Read more
From $5,688/mo
9.9
See details
Verified
Best of 2025
Sunrise Of Dix Hills - image 1

Sunrise Of Dix Hills

337 Deer Park Road, Huntington Station, NY 11746

Assisted Living , Memory Care

Sunrise of Dix Hills offers a welcoming and vibrant senior living community nestled within a picturesque Victorian-style estate. Residents are greeted with an atmosphere that promotes independence while ensuring safety and comfort. The community is renowned for its exceptional care and medical services, including a 24-hour nursing team and comprehensive healthcare support. Residents benefit from v...
...Read more
From $8,299/mo
9.9
See details
Verified
Sunrise Of Plainview - image 1

Sunrise Of Plainview

1231 Old Country Road, Plainview, NY 11803

Assisted Living , Memory Care

"Our Fathers Lead Care Staffer (Kamla) does a wonderful job taking care of him. She is kind, thorough, and professional in taking care of his every need. Her interaction with him shows just how dedicated she is to her job. We are completely at ease knowing Dad is being taken care of at the highest level. Kamla - thank you for all you do!" - John/Joseph
...Read more
From $8,299/mo
9.9
See details
Wondering if home care might be a better fit?
Sometimes staying at home with personalized care can be the better choice. Compare home care and assisted living options to see what fits your needs.
CareScout Quality Network
Atria Plainview - image 1

Atria Plainview

12 Washington Avenue , Plainview, NY 11803

Assisted Living , Independent Living

Nestled in the heart of Plainview, Atria Plainview offers a vibrant senior living community that prioritizes well-being and personalized care. With a dedicated 24-hour staff, residents experience a holistic approach to health, ensuring they remain engaged and supported throughout their daily lives. The community's commitment to personalized support means that whether residents are seeking independ...
...Read more
From $7,395/mo
9.9
See details

CareScout Quality Network
Atria Huntington - image 1

Atria Huntington

165 Beverly Road , Huntington Station, NY 11746

Assisted Living , Independent Living

Nestled in the heart of Huntington Station, Atria Huntington offers a vibrant and caring senior living community designed to provide peace of mind and comfort to its residents. With the assurance of 24-hour supervision and an array of health care services, including nursing support, medication management, and assistance with daily living activities, residents can enjoy their golden years in a secu...
...Read more
From $4,195/mo
9.8
See details
Verified
The Bristal At West Babylon - image 1

The Bristal At West Babylon

520 Montauk Highway, West Babylon, NY 11704

Assisted Living , Memory Care , Independent Living

Nestled on the South Shore of Long Island, The Bristal at West Babylon offers a vibrant and enriching environment for seniors seeking a fulfilling lifestyle. This community is renowned for its commitment to resident wellness and personalized care, ensuring that each individual receives the attention they deserve. The professional staff, available around-the-clock, provides assistance with daily ac...
...Read more
From $5,880/mo
9.7
See details
Verified
The Bristal At East Northport - image 1

The Bristal At East Northport

760 Larkfield Road, East Northport, NY 11731

Assisted Living , Memory Care , Independent Living

Nestled in the heart of Suffolk County, The Bristal at East Northport offers a welcoming community for seniors seeking a vibrant and supportive living environment. With an emphasis on personalized care and medical services, residents here are assured of receiving the attention they need, thanks to a dedicated team of professionals who are passionate about their work. The community is well-equipped...
...Read more
From $5,300/mo
9.8
See details
Understand your care options
With a personalized Care Plan, you’ll get clear guidance on care options and resources so you can find the right support.
carePricingPlans
Verified
Brandywine Huntington Terrace by Monarch - image 1

Brandywine Huntington Terrace by Monarch

70 Pinelawn Road, Melville, NY 11747

Assisted Living , Memory Care , Independent Living

Huntington Terrace, part of the esteemed Brandywine Senior Living community, is a vibrant and welcoming senior living community known for its exceptional care and medical services. Situated on a sprawling 12-acre campus, this community offers a harmonious blend of assisted living, independent living, and memory care, each tailored to meet the diverse needs of its residents. With a focus on revital...
...Read more
From $5,640/mo
9.7
See details
Verified
The Bristal at Massapequa - image 1

The Bristal at Massapequa

400 County Line Road, Massapequa, NY 11758

Assisted Living , Memory Care , Independent Living

"Wonderful community with great care. The community is aesthetically pleasing with good sized apartments. Both the assisted living and memory care communities offer great care via a tenured staff. " - Adam
From $5,100/mo
9.9
See details
Dominican Village - image 1

Dominican Village

565-567 Albany Avenue, Amityville, NY 11701

Assisted Living , Independent Living

Dominican Village stands as a beacon of comprehensive and compassionate senior living, nestled within the charming neighborhood of Amityville. This thriving community, established by the Sisters of St. Dominic of Amityville, New York, offers both Independent and Assisted Living services, with an emphasis on personal care and wellness. Residents benefit from a robust range of healthcare services, i...
...Read more
From $5,900/mo
9.8
See details
The Arbors at Islandia East and West - image 1

The Arbors at Islandia East and West

1515 Veterans Memorial Highway, Islandia, NY 11749

Assisted Living

"very nice people!" - mike
From $5,600/mo
9.6
See details
Missionary Sisters of St. Benedict - image 1

Missionary Sisters of St. Benedict

350 Cuba Hill Road, Huntington, NY 11743

Assisted Living

The Missionary Sisters Of St. Benedict is a vibrant senior living community nestled in the heart of Huntington, New York. This large community is dedicated to providing exceptional care and medical services to its residents, ensuring a comfortable and supportive environment for all. With a comprehensive range of healthcare services, including 12-16 hour nursing, medication management, and 24-hour ...
...Read more
From $6,900/mo
9.4
See details
Islip Pearl Garden

Islip Pearl Garden

36 Locust Avenue, Islip, NY 11751

Assisted Living

"The staff is very polite. The staff Pearl Gardens has been there in addressing my problem." - James
From $6,900/mo
8.4
See details
The Arbors at Hauppauge - image 1

The Arbors at Hauppauge

1740 Express Drive South, Hauppauge, NY 11788

Assisted Living

Nestled in the heart of Hauppauge, The Arbors at Hauppauge is a vibrant senior living community that prioritizes the health and well-being of its residents. This luxurious community offers a range of medical services, ensuring that residents receive the highest standard of care. Residents benefit from 12-16 hour nursing care, a 24-hour call system, and supervision, as well as assistance with daily...
...Read more
From $5,400/mo
9.1
See details
Verified
Gurwin Jewish Fay J. Lindner Residence - image 1

Gurwin Jewish Fay J. Lindner Residence

50 Hauppauge Road, Commack, NY 11725

Assisted Living

Nestled within the serene landscapes of Long Island, the Gurwin Jewish Fay J. Lindner Residence offers an inviting and vibrant community for seniors seeking a supportive living environment. This community stands out for its commitment to providing exceptional care and medical services, ensuring residents enjoy peace of mind and a high quality of life. Residents benefit from a comprehensive range o...
...Read more
From $5,900/mo
7.7
See details
Bayview Home for Adults - image 1

Bayview Home for Adults

143 East Main Street, Babylon, NY 11702

Assisted Living , Independent Living

Nestled in the vibrant heart of Babylon Village, Bayview Home for Adults is a welcoming senior living community that offers both assisted and independent living options. This large community is designed to provide residents with a safe and socially engaging environment where they can enjoy a fulfilling lifestyle. The community's central location ensures residents have easy access to a variety of l...
...Read more
From $4,750/mo
6.4
See details
Verified
Babylon Beach House Home for Adults - image 1

Babylon Beach House Home for Adults

23 Yacht Club Road, Babylon, NY 11702

Assisted Living

Dominican Village, a distinguished senior living community founded by the Sisters of St. Dominic of Amityville, New York, is committed to providing an environment that honors the sacredness of life and the dignity of each resident. This not-for-profit community offers a nurturing setting where seniors can thrive, supported by a comprehensive range of care and medical services tailored to promote t...
...Read more
From $4,910/mo
6.4
See details
New Development
Netherbay at Bayshore

Netherbay at Bayshore

36 South Clinton Avenue, Bay Shore, NY 11706

Assisted Living

From $4,695/mo
6
See details
Elmore Home for Adults

Elmore Home for Adults

330 Elmore Street, Central Islip, NY 11722

Assisted Living

Elmore Home For Adults is a welcoming senior living community nestled in the heart of Central Islip, New York. As a medium-sized community, Elmore offers an intimate setting where residents can receive personalized care and attention. The community is well-regarded for its comprehensive care and medical services, ensuring residents' well-being is always a top priority. With a robust mental wellnes...
...Read more
From $3,800/mo
5.5
See details
1 - 20 of 22 results

Top rated assisted living in West Islip, NY

In West Islip, New York, there are 22 assisted living communities, with 15 rated above 8. The top-rated facilities include Brighton Gardens Of Saddle River, Thrive at Montvale, Sunrise Of New City, Sunrise of Franklin Lakes, and Sunrise of Woodcliff Lake. The area predominantly features large communities, totaling 19, with only 2 medium and 1 small community. Seniorly has recently facilitated 1 move and 7 tours, with local advisors Mike McClernon and Jasmine Fung available for assistance.
20+
Assisted living communities analyzed
1,020+
Comprehensive reviews
250+
Community photographs
Verified
Brighton Gardens Of Saddle River - image 1

Brighton Gardens Of Saddle River

5 Boroline Road, Saddle River, NJ 07458

Assisted Living , Memory Care

" Brighton Gardens of Saddle River has left a good impression on me. I've seen mostly positive reviews from residents and their families. Personally, I appreciate the cleanliness, cozy atmosphere, and the range of activities available. The staff are friendly, caring, and attentive, making me feel at ease. The food is generally satisfying, although there have been some mixed opinions. While the cost..." - Vanessa
...Read more
From $6,931/mo
9.9
See details
Verified
Best of 2025
Thrive at Montvale - image 1

Thrive at Montvale

110 Summit Avenue, Montvale, NJ 07645

Assisted Living , Memory Care , Independent Living

"A home away from home best describes Thrive at Montvale. Incredible staff... very attentive to members needs... caring, great activities , good food, clean environment ,beautiful and nicely done apartments. Thrive at Montvale is a place to be. A great community for our loved ones. We give good Kudos to Sahar and the new team. " - Chinny
...Read more
From $8,230/mo
9.9
See details
Verified
Sunrise Of New City - image 1

Sunrise Of New City

233 North Main Street, New City, NY 10956

Assisted Living , Memory Care

Sunrise of New City is a vibrant senior living community that prides itself on delivering exceptional care and medical services to its residents. With a dedicated team of experienced caregivers, the community ensures that each resident receives personalized attention tailored to their unique health needs and preferences. On-site, residents have access to a range of health care services, including ...
...Read more
From $7,205/mo
9.9
See details
Verified
Sunrise of Franklin Lakes - image 1

Sunrise of Franklin Lakes

728 Franklin Avenue, Franklin Lakes, NJ 07417

Assisted Living , Memory Care

Sunrise of Franklin Lakes offers a welcoming haven for seniors, nestled within a lush 4.7-acre community that captures the charm of American Colonial architecture. The residence is thoughtfully designed to provide comfort and safety, with large windows that allow natural light to illuminate the interiors and offer serene views of the forested surroundings. Residents can bask in a vibrant atmospher...
...Read more
From $8,573/mo
9.9
See details
Verified
Sunrise of Woodcliff Lake - image 1

Sunrise of Woodcliff Lake

430 Chestnut Ridge Road, Woodcliff Lake, NJ 07677

Assisted Living , Memory Care

Sunrise of Woodcliff Lake is a vibrant senior living community that prides itself on providing exceptional care and medical services to its residents. Nestled in the charming neighborhood of Woodcliff Lake, NJ, this community is designed to cater to the unique health and well-being needs of older adults. With a dedicated team of care managers, Sunrise of Woodcliff Lake ensures that each resident r...
...Read more
From $6,414/mo
9.8
See details

Best value assisted living in West Islip, NY

In West Islip, New York, the best value assisted living communities, noted for their high ratings and low cost of care, include Brightview Lake Tappan, The Chelsea at Washington Township, Brandywine Mahwah by Monarch, and Promenade at Chestnut Ridge. This conclusion is based on the analysis of 1,016 reviews and 9 price data points.
The average price of these communities is $165 lower than the maximum price of similar assisted living communities in West Islip, NY
$5,735
$5,430
$5,900
Verified
Brightview Lake Tappan - image 1

Brightview Lake Tappan

31 Hunt Road, Orangeburg, NY 10962

Assisted Living , Memory Care , Independent Living

"There is much to praise at Brightview. The staff is wonderful. Caring, cheerful, professional. The facility is very well maintained, clean, bright and beautiful. However, The dining experience is awful.Meal choices are poor. Someone thought the choices are determined by corporate headquarters, but I don't know if that is true. Food is bland, often tasteless. Food delivery is slow. It usually take..." - lucy
...Read more
From $4,880/mo
9.6
See details
New Development
The Chelsea at Washington Township - image 1

The Chelsea at Washington Township

620 Pascack Road, Washington Township, NJ 07676

Assisted Living , Memory Care

The Chelsea at Washington Township is set to become a vibrant hub for seniors seeking an enriching lifestyle in Bergen County. Nestled conveniently off Pascack Road, the community offers a serene yet dynamic environment for those looking for Assisted Living and Memory Care. The location is complemented by its proximity to essential services and leisure spots, making it an ideal destination for sen...
...Read more
From $7,770/mo
9.3
See details
Verified
Brandywine Mahwah by Monarch - image 1

Brandywine Mahwah by Monarch

814 Wyckoff Avenue, Mahwah, NJ 07430

Assisted Living , Memory Care

Brandywine Living at Mahwah is a vibrant senior living community that prides itself on providing an exceptional standard of care and medical services. The community offers a comprehensive range of health care services, ensuring residents receive the support they need around the clock. With 12-16 hour nursing care, a 24-hour call system, and supervision, residents are assured of immediate assistanc...
...Read more
From $5,890/mo
9.3
See details
Promenade at Chestnut Ridge - image 1

Promenade at Chestnut Ridge

168 Red Schoolhouse Road, Chestnut Ridge, NY 10977

Assisted Living , Independent Living

Promenade At Chestnut Ridge is a vibrant senior living community nestled in the charming area of Chestnut Ridge, New York. This expansive community is known for its comprehensive care and medical services, tailored to meet the diverse needs of its residents. With a strong focus on health and wellness, the community provides 12-16 hour nursing care, a mental wellness program, and 24-hour supervisio...
...Read more
From $4,400/mo
9.3
See details

Advisor recommended assisted living in West Islip, NY

In West Islip, New York, Seniorly's local advisors, Mike McClernon and Jasmine Fung, recommend 12 out of 22 assisted living communities. Notable recommended communities include Brightview Lake Tappan, Brandywine Mahwah by Monarch, Promenade at Chestnut Ridge, and The Bristal At Woodcliff Lake.
Headshot.jpegJF
Jasmine Fung

West Islip Seniorly Advisor

9.3
Average Seniorly Community score of advisor recommended communities
4 assisted living communities
Verified
Brightview Lake Tappan - image 1

Brightview Lake Tappan

31 Hunt Road, Orangeburg, NY 10962

Assisted Living , Memory Care , Independent Living

"There is much to praise at Brightview. The staff is wonderful. Caring, cheerful, professional. The facility is very well maintained, clean, bright and beautiful. However, The dining experience is awful.Meal choices are poor. Someone thought the choices are determined by corporate headquarters, but I don't know if that is true. Food is bland, often tasteless. Food delivery is slow. It usually take..." - lucy
...Read more
From $4,880/mo
9.6
See details
Verified
Brandywine Mahwah by Monarch - image 1

Brandywine Mahwah by Monarch

814 Wyckoff Avenue, Mahwah, NJ 07430

Assisted Living , Memory Care

Brandywine Living at Mahwah is a vibrant senior living community that prides itself on providing an exceptional standard of care and medical services. The community offers a comprehensive range of health care services, ensuring residents receive the support they need around the clock. With 12-16 hour nursing care, a 24-hour call system, and supervision, residents are assured of immediate assistanc...
...Read more
From $5,890/mo
9.3
See details
Promenade at Chestnut Ridge - image 1

Promenade at Chestnut Ridge

168 Red Schoolhouse Road, Chestnut Ridge, NY 10977

Assisted Living , Independent Living

Promenade At Chestnut Ridge is a vibrant senior living community nestled in the charming area of Chestnut Ridge, New York. This expansive community is known for its comprehensive care and medical services, tailored to meet the diverse needs of its residents. With a strong focus on health and wellness, the community provides 12-16 hour nursing care, a mental wellness program, and 24-hour supervisio...
...Read more
From $4,400/mo
9.3
See details
Verified
The Bristal At Woodcliff Lake - image 1

The Bristal At Woodcliff Lake

364 Chestnut Ridge Road, Woodcliff Lake, NJ 07677

Assisted Living , Memory Care , Independent Living

Nestled in the serene and picturesque landscape of Woodcliff Lake, The Bristal at Woodcliff Lake offers a vibrant and engaging senior living community where residents are surrounded by natural beauty and tranquility. With its proximity to tranquil lakes and quiet parks, the community provides a peaceful retreat while still being conveniently close to cultural and commercial centers. Residents enjo...
...Read more
From $6,700/mo
9.1
See details

Pet friendly assisted living in West Islip, NY

In West Islip, New York, pet-friendly assisted living options include Arbor Terrace Norwood and The Chelsea at New City. These communities accommodate residents with pets, providing a supportive environment for seniors who wish to keep their animal companions.
9.4
Average Seniorly Community score of pet friendly communities
2 assisted living communities
Verified
Arbor Terrace Norwood - image 1

Arbor Terrace Norwood

545 Tappan Road, Norwood, NJ 07648

Assisted Living , Memory Care

Arbor Terrace Norwood is a vibrant senior living community that provides an exceptional memory care experience, nestled in the scenic setting of Bergen County. With a focus on holistic wellness, the community is expertly designed to cater to seniors with Alzheimer's and other forms of dementia, ensuring safety, comfort, and peace of mind. The dedicated Evergreen team at Arbor Terrace is committed ...
...Read more
From $6,300/mo
9.5
See details
The Chelsea at New City

The Chelsea at New City

269 North Main Street, New City, NY 10956

Assisted Living , Memory Care

The Chelsea at New City is a welcoming senior living community, offering a vibrant and supportive environment for residents. Situated in the heart of a residential neighborhood, it provides easy access to a range of local amenities, including shops, restaurants, and medical services, ensuring that all needs can be met with convenience and ease. At The Chelsea at New City, health and wellness are ...
...Read more
From $6,795/mo
9.3
See details

Explore other types of communities in West Islip, NY

Independent Living

For active older adults who want to downsize to a home in a retirement community but don't need help to live independently.

Memory Care

A supervised and secured community designed to support engagement and quality of life for residents living with dementia.

Continuing Care Retirement Communities

For residents who want to age in place as their care needs change—from Independent Living to nursing care. Requires a buy-in fee.

Nursing Homes

For seniors with more serious medical needs who require skilled care following a hospitalization, illness, or surgery. Nursing Homes are also known as skilled nursing facilities.

Board and Care Home

Homes in residential neighborhoods that are equipped and staffed to provide daily care for a small number of residents.

Helpful resources

Assisted Living Facilities near West Islip, NY

Need help finding senior living options?

Get access to personalized senior living and care options.